Anybody successful getting paid strictly through signals? : r/Forex

The allure of making money strictly through following forex signals is strong, especially among newcomers to the trading world. The idea that one can simply execute trades based on signals provided by experienced traders or sophisticated algorithms—without needing to do any analysis themselves—is understandably appealing. In this article, we'll explore whether it's really feasible to earn a steady income solely by following forex signals, highlight the key features of this approach, and share real-life examples from traders who have attempted this strategy.

Key Features of Trading Strictly Through Forex Signals

  1. Simplicity: Trading based on signals simplifies the forex trading process. Traders don’t need to spend hours analyzing charts or learning complex trading strategies.

  2. Time-saving: For those with limited time, trading signals can be a significant advantage, as they provide quick suggestions on what and when to trade, saving immense amounts of time.

  3. Access to Expertise: Traders get insights from experienced professionals or automated systems, potentially leveling the playing field between novice and experienced traders.

  4. Diversified Trading: Many signal services offer a variety of signals for different currency pairs and trading styles, allowing users to diversify their trading activities.

Challenges of Relying Solely on Signals

  1. Cost: Quality forex signals often come at a price, either through a subscription model or a one-time payment for each signal. These costs can add up, especially if the profits from trading the signals do not outweigh the expenses.

  2. Risk of Dependency: Relying solely on signals can prevent traders from developing their own trading skills and market understanding, which are crucial for long-term success.

  3. Volatility and Misfires: The forex market is notoriously volatile. Signals that may have been profitable at one time can quickly become less so, and not all signal providers quickly update or recalibrate their signals based on real-time market changes.

Real-Life Examples

Case Study 1: The Novice Trader

John, a novice trader, decided to try trading exclusively using signals provided by a highly-rated forex signal service. The first few months were moderately successful; John followed the signals to the letter and managed to make a small but steady income. However, as market conditions shifted, the signals that were once reliable began to fail more frequently. John realized he was not equipped to adjust on his own without a deeper understanding of market dynamics. Ultimately, the losses began to pile up, and the subscription fees only added to his financial strain.

Case Study 2: The Side Hustler

Sarah, who worked a full-time job and traded forex as a side hustle, subscribed to a forex signal service that integrated artificial intelligence to adapt to changing market conditions. Sarah’s approach was more cautious; she used the signals as a secondary confirmation of her own basic analysis, which she had been cultivating. Over time, Sarah found that while the signals did help enhance her trading decisions, her success was not solely attributable to following the signals. Instead, it was her combined approach that helped her maintain profitability.


While there are examples of traders who have found moderate success trading strictly through signals, the consensus in the trading community, especially platforms like r/Forex, suggests that signals should not be relied upon as the sole method for trading decisions. Effective trading often requires a blend of personal market analysis, emotional control, and good risk management. For those looking to use forex signals, it may be more beneficial to view them as tools to supplement a broader, more comprehensive trading strategy rather than a standalone solution.